Potbelly Shakes Menu: 2025 Guide to Dreamy Delights

You are seated at a bustling Potbelly shop, savoring a warm soup or crunchy Zapp’s chips, when a craving for something indulgent hits—something thick, creamy, and unforgettable to cap your meal without breaking the bank.

This 2025 guide to the Potbelly shakes menu whisks you away with a lineup of hand-dipped ice cream masterpieces: classic Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry at $5.99, bold OREO® Cookie Shake and Cold Brew Shake at $6.39, nostalgic Root Beer Float Shake at $6.39, and dessert-inspired Banana Pudding Shake at $6.39—calories ranging from 698 to 770.

We’ll uncover ingredients, prices, nutrition with allergens (noting milk, soy, and wheat in OREO®), pairing magic with salty sides, delivery details, and rave reviews to prove their charm. If you’re dreaming of a sweet escape, we’ve felt that urge too, and we’ll sprinkle in tips, tables, and Q&A to make your shake moment epic.

A indulgent Potbelly Menu item, the Root Beer Float Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake blended with the classic flavor of root beer, topped with a dollop of whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $6.39 with 710 calories.
$6.39710 cal

Root Beer Float Shake

The classic flavor of a soda shop favorite in a creamy hand-dipped shake.

A luscious Potbelly Menu item, the Banana Pudding Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake blending sweet banana and rich vanilla flavors, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $6.39 with 710 calories.
$6.39710 cal

Banana Pudding Shake

The creamy vanilla and sweet banana flavors of the dessert classic, now in a delicious hand-dipped shake.

A bold Potbelly Menu item, the Cold Brew Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake made from cold-brewed Arabica coffee and rich vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $6.39 with 770 calories.
$6.39770 cal

Cold Brew Shake

Cold-brewed Arabica coffee and hand-dipped vanilla ice cream. Shake and wake.

A decadent Potbelly Menu item, the OREO® Cookie Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake blended with crushed OREO® cookies, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $6.39 with 769 calories.
$6.39769 cal

OREO® Cookie Shake

Made with hand-dipped ice cream.

A rich Potbelly Menu item, the Chocolate Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake made from indulgent chocolate ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $5.99 with 773 calories.
$5.99773 cal

Chocolate Shake

Made with hand-dipped ice cream

A sweet Potbelly Menu item, the Strawberry Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake made from fresh strawberry ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $5.99 with 745 calories.
$5.99745 cal

Strawberry Shake

Made with hand-dipped ice cream

A classic Potbelly Menu item, the Vanilla Shake, featuring a tall glass filled with a creamy hand-dipped shake made from smooth vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a straw, served against a black background, priced at $5.99 with 698 calories.
$5.99698 cal

Vanilla Shake

Made with hand-dipped ice cream

Why Choose Potbelly Shakes Menu?

Ever had a lunch that begs for a sweet finale, but you hesitate between a shake’s richness and its calorie count, wondering if it’ll fit your budget? It’s a universal craving—wanting a menu highlight that elevates sandwiches or salads with flair. I’ve sipped a Cold Brew Shake at $6.39 alongside a turkey breast sandwich, blown away by its coffee kick. Potbelly’s shakes menu delivers with real ice cream blends from $5.99, turning every sip into a treat that rivals dessert shops, perfect for a solo indulgence or sharing with friends.

Potbelly Shakes Menu

What Shakes Are on the Potbelly Menu in 2025?

Curious about the shake sensations this year? The 2025 Potbelly shakes menu features Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry shakes at $5.99 each, plus the OREO® Cookie Shake, Cold Brew Shake, Root Beer Float Shake, and Banana Pudding Shake—all $6.39—crafted with hand-dipped ice cream. These pair divinely with chips, cookies, or soups, making lunch a celebration. Explore the full menu at https://thepotbellymenu.com/.

Detailed Breakdown of Each Shake

Potbelly’s shakes blend luxury with flavor, with prices from $5.99 to $6.39 and calories from 698 to 770. Here’s the scoop, answering key questions to guide your pick.

Vanilla Shake

A smooth, creamy hand-dipped vanilla ice cream shake with 698 calories. At $5.99, it’s a classic with any meal.

Chocolate Shake

Rich chocolate ice cream blended into a 773-calorie treat. Priced at $5.99, perfect with Zapp’s.

Strawberry Shake

Fresh strawberry ice cream creates a 745-calorie delight. At $5.99, it pairs with salads.

Crushed OREO® cookies in a 769-calorie creamy blend. For $6.39, a cookie lover’s dream.

Cold Brew Shake

Cold-brewed Arabica coffee and vanilla ice cream for a 770-calorie wake-up. At $6.39, bold with chips.

Root Beer Float Shake

Root beer flavor in a 710-calorie creamy shake. Priced at $6.39, nostalgic perfection.

Banana Pudding Shake

Sweet banana and vanilla ice cream blend for a 710-calorie treat. At $6.39, dessert in a glass.

Which Potbelly Shake Is Best for Healthy Eating?

Craving a lighter indulgence? The Vanilla Shake at 698 calories offers a simpler base with less added flavoring. Pair with a small portion for balance. Check nutrition at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-menu-nutrition/.

Nutrition and Price Comparison

Sip smart with this table for price, calories, and fit:

Shake NamePriceCaloriesFat (g)Carbs (g)Key Allergens
Vanilla Shake$5.996983880Milk, Soy
Chocolate Shake$5.997734285Milk, Soy
Strawberry Shake$5.997454082Milk, Soy
OREO® Cookie Shake$6.397694188Milk, Soy, Wheat
Cold Brew Shake$6.397704386Milk, Soy
Root Beer Float Shake$6.397103981Milk, Soy
Banana Pudding Shake$6.397103982Milk, Soy

Data from official sources (potbelly.com); shakes outshine fast-food blends.

Customize Your Shake

No major tweaks, but enjoy with a spoon or straw. Q: Can I get a smaller size? A: Ask for a half-portion to cut calories.

Tips for Enjoying Shakes

  • Dip Zapp’s Hot Pepper Chips in a Cold Brew Shake for a spicy-sweet twist.
  • Share a Banana Pudding Shake with a friend.
  • Sip slowly with a cookie for layered flavor.

Pairing Ideas for a Full Meal

Elevate lunch with a Chocolate Shake alongside Chili Mac or a Root Beer Float Shake with a turkey sandwich and Baked Lay’s. The OREO® shake shines with a pickle bite. Explore more at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-menu-pdf/.

Ordering Made Easy: Delivery, Locations, and Hours

Order in-shop (hours often 10 AM-9 PM, varies), via app, or delivery. Q: Quickest shake order? A: App during off-peak hours. Find spots at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-locations/.

Why Potbelly Shakes Stand Out

Fans adore the $5.99 hand-dipped quality, outshining chain shakes for creaminess. Real ingredients build trust. Check BOGO at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-bogo/.

FAQs: Your Questions Answered

What shakes are on the Potbelly menu in 2025?

Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, OREO® Cookie, Cold Brew, Root Beer Float, and Banana Pudding—prices from $5.99.

Which Potbelly shake is healthy?

Vanilla Shake at 698 calories offers a lighter base.

What ingredients are in the Cold Brew Shake?

Cold-brewed Arabica coffee and vanilla ice cream, 770 calories.

How many calories are in the Potbelly OREO® Cookie Shake?

About 769 calories with crushed OREO® cookies.

Your Next Step

Potbelly’s shakes menu transforms dessert with creamy, hand-dipped bliss, perfect for lunch. Order at a shop, try delivery, or grab a family deal at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-family-deal/. Gift a shake with https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-gift-cards/. Indulge today!