Potbelly Cookies Menu: 2025 Guide to Irresistible Sweet Treats

You are finishing lunch at a Potbelly shop, eyeing the counter for a sweet finish to your sandwich or soup, but wondering if cookies will satisfy without adding too many calories or costing a fortune.

This 2025 guide to the Potbelly cookies menu answers that, featuring warm Oatmeal Chocolate Chip at $2.79, buttery Sugar Cookie at $2.79, rich Chocolate Brownie Cookie at $2.79, chewy Dream Bar at $2.59, a Bag of Mini Cookies at $5.69, and the 6-Pack Cookie Box at $11.99—with calories around 420 for the box.

We’ll cover ingredients, prices, nutrition with allergens (noting wheat, dairy, eggs), pairing ideas with drinks or sides, delivery and location details, plus reviews to showcase their appeal. If you’re craving a dessert that complements your meal, we’ve been there too, and we’ll share tips, tables, and Q&A to pick the perfect treat.

Why Choose Potbelly Cookies?

Think back to those afternoons when lunch feels incomplete without a sweet bite, but you’re torn between a cookie’s warmth and a bar’s chewiness, worried about calories or sharing costs. It’s a relatable moment—wanting fresh desserts on the menu to pair with salads or chips. I’ve enjoyed an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie at $2.79 with a Sprite, loving its cozy flavor. Potbelly cookies menu delivers with freshly baked options from $2.59, offering classics and unique bars, perfect for a solo treat or sharing with the 6-pack deal.

What Cookies Are on the Potbelly Menu in 2025?

Wondering what’s baking this year? The 2025 Potbelly cookies menu features Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar Cookie, Chocolate Brownie Cookie—all $2.79 each, Dream Bar at $2.59, Bag of Mini Cookies at $5.69 for a dozen, and the 6-Pack Cookie Box at $11.99 for six favorites or an assortment. These pair beautifully with drinks, soups, or sandwiches, making dessert a highlight. Check the full menu at https://thepotbellymenu.com/.

Detailed Breakdown of Each Cookie

Potbelly cookies menu bring fresh-baked goodness, with prices from $2.59 to $11.99 and calories around 420 for the 6-pack. Here’s the rundown, answering key questions to guide your choice.

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

This golden cookie, studded with chocolate chips, offers warm, chewy comfort. Priced at $2.79, it’s a classic with drinks.

Sugar Cookie

A buttery cookie sprinkled with coarse sugar, baked fresh daily. At $2.79, it’s simple and satisfying.

Chocolate Brownie Cookie

A rich, dark chocolate cookie with a fudgy bite. For $2.79, it pairs well with coffee.

Dream Bar

A chewy oatmeal bar loaded with caramel and chocolate chips. At $2.59, it’s a unique treat.

Bag of Mini Cookies

A dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies for on-the-go snacking. Priced at $5.69, perfect for sharing.

6-Pack Cookie Box

Choose six favorites or an assortment, totaling 420 calories. At $11.99, ideal for groups.

Which Potbelly Cookie Is Best for Healthy Eating?

Looking for a lighter option? The Sugar Cookie, at an estimated 150-200 calories (based on similar recipes), offers a simple treat with less chocolate or caramel. Check nutrition at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-menu-nutrition/ for updates.

Nutrition and Price Comparison in Potbelly Cookies Menu

Compare with this table for price, calories, and fit:

Item Name	Price	Calories (Est.)	Fat (g)	Carbs (g)	Key Allergens
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip	$2.79	200-250	10	30	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs
Sugar Cookie	$2.79	150-200	8	25	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs
Chocolate Brownie Cookie	$2.79	200-250	12	28	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs
Dream Bar	$2.59	200-250	10	35	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs
Bag of Mini Cookies	$5.69	200-250 (dozen)	10	30	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs
6-Pack Cookie Box	$11.99	420 (6)	60	180	Wheat, Dairy, Eggs

Estimated calories based on similar baked goods; allergens confirmed.

Customize Your Cookie

Mix and match the 6-pack for variety or grab minis for portion control. Q: Can I make a low-sugar cookie? A: Stick to Sugar Cookie for a less sweet option.

Tips for Enjoying Cookies

• Warm an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip with a shake for a melty treat.
• Share the 6-pack with friends at lunch.
• Pair Dream Bar with a Sprite for contrast.

Pairing Ideas for a Full Meal

Enhance your meal with an Oatmeal Chocolate Chip alongside Chili Mac or a Sugar Cookie with a turkey sandwich and Coke. The 6-pack fits any group lunch. Explore more at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-menu-pdf/.

Ordering Made Easy: Delivery, Locations, and Hours

Order in-shop (hours often 10 AM-9 PM, varies), via app, or delivery. Q: Quickest cookie order? A: App during off-peak hours. Find locations at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-locations/.

Why Potbelly Cookies Stand Out

Fans love the $2.79 fresh-baked deals, beating store-bought cookies for taste. Quality ingredients earn trust. Check BOGO at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-bogo/.

FAQs: Your Questions Answered

Your Next Step

Potbelly’s cookies menu delights with fresh-baked treats, perfect for dessert. Order at a shop, try delivery, or grab a family deal at https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-family-deal/. Gift sweetness with https://thepotbellymenu.com/potbelly-gift-cards/. Treat yourself today!